Tuesday, October 24, 2006

Formula 1, post-Schumi

Ever since this humble blog began, the gap between posts has been increasing exponentially. Well, over are the student days. And I can finally tell people the line I've heard to death, 'I am busy'. Also, the posts are now more topical and less personal or about routine things.

So Michael Schumacher has called it a day. Sportsmen should retire at a point when fans would be begging for them to stay. Not wait for the natural demise and deterioration of a talent. Not see an erstwhile superhuman become a mere mortal like us. Schumacher's falls somewhere in between. He didn't go out on a high, he wasn't at his peak, so fans wouldn't pose the question "Why now?". Ofcourse the tifosi would disagree. Neither was he bad enough for people to question his presence in Formula 1. But his time was up.

Nevertheless, the future looks good. The youngest double world champion, Fernando Alonso, displacing Schumi himself. Ice-cool Kimi Raikkonen, now in arguably the fastest car in the paddock. Jenson 'Eternal Loser' Button, who used to be the next big thing, will announce a title challenge for the nth season with Honda and go on to top winter testing to keep the sponsors happy. Some exciting youngsters in Kubica, Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg.

It is the future of the regulations that is cause for worry. Ferrari's domination necessitated some change in regulations. But they did not stop once the sport reached good health. They have gone from bizarre to diabolical. I disagree with more than a few.

Sport is about rewarding the good and not punishing the poor. And the 2 race engine rule and erstwhile one lap qualifying did exactly that, they punished the poor. The 2 race engine rule was said to cut down engine development costs. But rather I think they should have increased since teams would have to spend more to develop an engine to last 2 GP's. And a 10 position penalty for an engine change punishes teams with unreliable engines!

Coming to the one lap qualifying. Good riddance to that, not that I am a fan of the current one. Drivers who finished last would go first to register their timed lap. Going first meant a disadvantage on an unused track. As a result it handicapped their chances to achieve a good position. A poor qualifying would further hinder their prospects in the race. As a result teams get stuck in a vicious cycle of mediocrity. The winners would meanwhile continue to register faster times as they would go out last.

Now the current system. I am a purist. IMHO, the current qulaifying system has been 'American-ized', i.e. rings a bit hollow and act as gimmicks. Session 1,2..., knockouts, fuel credits, race fuel levels blah blah blah. I crave for the return of the 60 minute 12 flying laps system. Gone are the days when drivers would time their flying laps just in time to start before the chequered flag was waved to end the 60 minutes. The mad rush in the last few minutes to give it one more shot. The point of qualifying is to decide the 'fastest' driver per say. So give em only enough fuel to last the laps and level the playing field and then lets really have the deserving pole sitter. No more deciding your race strategy before qualifying, leave that for raceday.

The tire changes were thankfully bought back this season. Pitstops ceased to be pitstops without the tire changes last season. One tire supplier, I can live with that. If only it will further level the playing field.

Formula 1 is seen as the pinnacle of cutting edge technology. Freezing engine developments for another 2 (or something yrs) is silly IMHO. Let the development continue. F1 is not F1 without all the technology on view.

Another aspect the FIA seems to harp on is slowing down the cars. Despite a raft of regulations every year, this never happens as record laps are registered at track after track. They rather concentrate their brain cells on trying to cars the safer and ensure that the speeds are not increasing beyond an unsustainable limit.

My expected 3 horse race for the title has not materialised for the last 2 seasons. Ferrari last season and McLaren this season went AWOL for different reasons. All the 3 big teams, Ferrari, McLaren and Renault go into the next season with a hint of uncertainty and unknown. The reshuffling of Ferrari with Jean Todt's promotion to CEO of Ferrari and Ross Brawn's sabbatical is underway. Coupled with the fact that the 2 main title contenders in Alonso and Raikkonen will be in new teams. Only one team and driver with a hint of continuity comes to mind. None other than the ex-next big thing, Jenson 'Eternal Loser' Button whos been at Honda for 2-3 years (or more). Could he finally step up to the plate and give me the 3 horse race that I crave for?

Gentleman, start your engines... err sorry... not for another few months. I can barely wait.

3 comments:

Yatin said...

I think it's unwise to say "Schumi's time was up". I still believe he would have been mentally and physically fit enough to perform at the highest level. However, he did the right thing by stepping aside for the young and talented Massa and for Ferrari's long-term gain, Kimi Raikkonen. He has already achieved "F1 Nirvana"!

I think the "Americanized" qualifying format is a pretty good one. It demands strategy (in Q3) and tests single-lap performance (Q1 and Q2) as well. Consider the qualifying sessions at Interlagos this year in light of the old 60-min format - Schumi broke the lap record in Q2 but his car wasn't up to its best in Q3 and he started 10th on the grid. If he'd lapped in his record-breaking flyer in the previous format and then sat in the garage for the rest of the session drinking beer, he still would have been on pole. Doesn't it mean you're rewarding a car that was not 100% fit throughout the session? I don't even want to discuss the merits and shortcomings of the one lap qualifying format - that was simply ludicrous!

I can understand your disillusionment about rule changes that were supposedly enforced to "reduce costs". That was a sham. It was a desperate attempt to curb Ferrari's dominance but well, they are back on top! Engine homologation is further going to ruin chances of seeing other teams up the ante.

All said and done, I'm glad Formula 1 is FINALLY on the road to a great future. A few years ago, it had become similar to today's tennis world - one man ruling the roost with no suitable match to challenge him. With major shuffling underway, great talented young drivers entering the fray and even new teams like Super Aguri really striving to pull up their socks (Sato's drive in Brazil), it's going to be quite exciting. Not that I expect more than a 3-pronged battle for the championship, but there's hope for improvement. And I'm most definitely looking forward to seeing the Iceman in a scarlet suit!

Sportsnob said...

Nice Post.
I agree, F1 is being made highly regulated and unnecessarily so, IMO.

Did Schumi have one more Drivers' title in him? I think so... a la Sampras. It would have taken a lot and a slightly better car but he could have done it.

Also, I think Button has lost his chance. Some bad career moves I think. Alonso and Raikkonen will be a good battle. But that's the only battle I foresee for the next 2 seasons. The youngsters, I don't know. I would have loved to see mark Webber in a good car. He is good...

Ravi Gurnani said...

@yatin - i am of the view that qualifying should be simply about the fastest car under similar conditions. coming to the current format. it has happened in a race that a car eliminated in one of the knockouts has had a faster time that the ultimate pole sitter!! i cant recall the race. so it means the cars dont have to be at their fastest all the time.

we are past the point where we need rule changes to break team hegemonies.

new teams always excite me. i am interested in seeing the progress aguri can make and if toyota and red bull can reach the next level given their lavish budgets.

@sportsnob - thanx. i think schumi still had a title in him. but he would have had to fight hard for it. but then losing to the current crop would prolly sully his retirement and i think he quit with dignity now.

its time for button to deliver and cut the big talk. hes blundered in his moves. i think he was or had the chance to go to renault if i remember correctly.

and webber needs a decent car to be a serious contender. he doesnt have raw pace but is a sturdy performer. interesting to see fisichella next yr as a number one driver for the constructers champions